Someone asks you what you would like for dinner and you open your mouth and nothing comes out. Not because you're being difficult, but because you genuinely do not know. You know what the children will eat, what is in the fridge, what is quick, what your partner had at lunch so won't want again, and somewhere under all that information there should be a small voice saying what you would like, and it has gone quiet. So you say “I don't mind, whatever's easiest,” and everyone thinks you are being easygoing, and you half think so too.
It starts much earlier in the day than dinner. Most mornings the hand goes into the cupboard and takes whichever cup is at the front. It is not a decision, it is barely an action; the kettle is already boiling and there are lunches to make or a bus to catch, and who has time to choose a cup? But try, one morning, stopping in front of the shelf. There will be a chipped one you keep for no good reason, a heavy one that keeps tea hot, a pretty one somebody gave you, and if you let your hand hover for two seconds and ask, absurdly, which one do I want, you may feel something small shift. The day has begun with a choice that was yours.
That sounds too small to matter, and I think it matters more than we expect. Psychologists who study motivation have written for decades about autonomy, the sense that what we do comes from ourselves rather than from pressure outside us. In an influential paper on self-determination theory, Ryan and Deci (2000) argued that autonomy, alongside competence and relatedness, is a basic psychological need, and that settings which support a sense of choice tend to go with greater motivation and well-being. Autonomy in their sense is not doing everything alone or doing whatever you like. It is the felt sense that what you do is, in some meaningful way, yours (Ryan & Deci, 2000).
If you carry a lot, you can spend whole days with very little of that feeling. The shape of the day is set by work, school, care, illness and other people's needs, and most of it was chosen in the large sense, because you chose these people and this life, but moment to moment it can feel like being carried along by a current: respond, respond, respond. You cannot always change the current. What you can do is find the small places where the choice is genuinely yours and make it on purpose, the cup, the route to the bus, the first thing you eat, the scarf, the window you open, the order you do the dull jobs in. They are tiny, and they are real, and each one is a chance to ask the question that has gone quiet: what do I want?
I think of it as exercising the muscle of preference, which weakens in a lot of us through years of not being used. Asked where we would like to go on holiday, we name somewhere the family will enjoy, and we mean it kindly, and the muscle gets a little weaker. It needs gentle exercise before it can carry anything heavy, before it can help you answer the bigger questions about work or love or how you want to spend your one Saturday. So start with the cup. Open the cupboard, let your hand hover, and notice which one feels right this morning: the heavy one, because you need to be held, the light one, because you want to feel quick, or the bright one, because it is grey outside and you could do with some colour. Choose it, fill it, and hold it in both hands for one breath. You have already done one thing today that was entirely yours, and by dinner you may even have an answer.
Ritual Invitation
Every morning this week, before your first drink, stop at the cupboard and choose your cup on purpose. Ask silently, which one do I want today, and notice if the answer surprises you. Then find one other small choice later in the day and make it deliberately, as your own.
Your Turn
What is the smallest choice in your day that could be truly yours, and which cup would you reach for this morning if nobody else's needs came first?
Keep the Thread
Each week The Pulse brings one essay and one ritual like this, free. Join The Pulse — free
Return to Yourself, the first Witch in Progress book, is full of small practices like this one. Read Return to Yourself
If this work has given you something, you can help keep it independent. Support Witch in Progress
References
Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.55.1.68
Keep reading
